December 2010 - A Right State

1) Associate! December 2010 

2) Edge Funding, A Course in Finance for Teachers

3) Democratic Money?

.

  

1) Associate! December 2010

Click image to subscribe

 

Lead: Assets for All ResPublica and NESTA Joint Publication

A Sign of Our Time: Sugaring the Pill

Feature: Concerning Coalition  Christopher Houghton Budd

Feature: Understanding Rights Life Rudolf Steiner

Glossary:  R : Risk 

News and Views:  Editors in Academia, Reports, Discussion

Accounting Corner: Right Money Stephen Torr

Click here to subscribe

Editorial

This month's issue, themed 'A Right State', looks at current debates on the role of the state in the light of what Rudolf Steiner describes as the 'rights life', see page 5. We begin with the kind of views on community assets typical of Philip Blond, whose think-tank, ResPublica, is enjoying considerable influence in macro policy circles. The emphasis on a new enfranchisement of the poor and the community is worth noting, although whether these are real categories or merely alluring abstractions remains to be seen.

One very obvious community asset is credit creation and fractional reserve lending. Sign of Our Time highlights a recent move by the British MP Douglas Carswell to redefine the nature of banking. The point is not whether the proposed changes are achieved, but that such ideas are abroad the land, requiring not only a rethink of the relationship between rights life and economic life, which is what money entails, but a change in behaviour. To be historically meaningful, the scale and scope of such changes will need to be more substantial than many people contemplate. The thought of depoliticising economic life, and its corollary of stripping political life of its economic mandate, is unlikely to sit easily in today's status quo, but in Concerning Coalition Christopher Houghton Budd brings a fresh perspective by pointing out that 'if we could but settle on one paradigm as regards economic affairs, political life would become much more coalitional, and in tune, one could argue, with its own logic.'

Providing the core reference for this issue, Rudolf Steiner's idea of rights life is set out, the subtlety of which when compared to property rights and human rights, for example, it is important to appreciate. The last part of the Friends' Page also features extracts from a readers' discussion on monetary matters. Accounting Corner completes the issue with its focus on Right Money.

2) Edge Funding, A Course in Finance for Teachers

Modern finance through Rudolf Steiner's eyes - An introductory course with Dr. Christopher Houghton Budd. Follow this link for details

There is perhaps no greater challenge today than understanding modern finance. Many of today's pressures derive from the way we behave or are expected to behave in regard to finance; pressures that are only increased by lack of understanding and the bewilderment and disempowerment this can bring. This is even more the case if one sees finance as something merely outer and not as the deeply spiritual event it in reality is. By bringing together two themes normally kept apart - finance and the threshold - and by spanning from the big picture to hands-on, from comprehension to competence, this course is designed to equip participants with an appreciation of modern finance, cladding them against an often otherwise harsh environment. 

'Financial markets are like the mirror of mankind, revealing every hour of every working day the way we value ourselves and the resources of the world around us [so that] it is not the fault of the mirror if it reflects our blemishes as clearly as our beauty.' - Niall Ferguson

'It means extinction and death to the economic body when we deprive the individual of his initiative, which must proceed from his spirit and take part in the ordering of the means of production purely for the benefit of human society.' - Rudolf Steiner

12 Saturdays (9.00 to 10.00), 26 September 2010 to 9 July 2011

3) Democratic Money?

There are increasing calls for 'monetary reform' based on 'democratic' thinking. But does money itself need to be reformed or simply understood in its true nature?

The following extract from Rare Albion - A Monetary Allegory takes a glance askance at the monetary reform movement; it follows the progress of Victor on his journey towards an understanding of the nature of money today.

"Directly opposite, another door appeared in the blue wall. Victor crossed the courtyard to read what was written on it: 'Committee Against Financiers (CAF). All welcome.' Inside was another loggia in which a large crowd had gathered and were intensely listening to a lecture on the double invoicing of the goldsmiths, the evils of fractional reserve lending, and the need to return to 100% reserve cover backed by gold. It clearly had not occurred to the speaker that the way of life he was used to and which enabled him to live the way he did, would have to be given up if people did what he urged upon them. To deny credit creation is to stifle creativity. To constrain the banks is not the same thing as to develop independence from them. As he worked his audience with a great deal of plausible reasoning and carefully selected statistics about the effect of compound interest rates and the need to do away with interest, he was oblivious of Reason as she quietly made her exit from the room, obscured from the audience by the fog of rhetoric by which everyone was now surrounded.

One member of the audience did not quite understand the logic of the speaker's argument and said so. The speaker, irritated by the absence of congratulation in the question, replied with an answer that left the questioner unimpressed. But, like St. Exupery's 'Little Prince', he clung to his enquiry and asked his question again in a slightly different way. “I thought you were one of us,” the speaker rejoined, managing with this remark to turn the entire audience against the interlocutor. And then, like an embarrassed minister in lesser-governed countries than Columbia, he sought out a more flattering question from a fellow member of his committee. Victor remembered his training in the Academy of Humbug. Humbug, he had been taught on the first day, is one thing when given out by those who really understand monetary science. Its purpose is to keep that science as a province of experts. But it is another thing when proffered by those unschooled. Then it has the effect of making citizens believe they are experts, when in fact they may well have been better advised to remain with their lay understanding. 

More than ever, Victor now knew his task was to be scientific without the humbug, to show people how money really worked and to equip them with concepts, arrangements and even accounting systems that spoke the truth about money, so that through their monetary behavior they could become enlightened citizens. “If people took at face value the arguments of this speaker (not to mention those lined up to follow him), they would simply find themselves cut off from their will forces, chasing a strategy that could never be implemented because it understood neither history nor banking. It stirred the will against others, an easy thing to do in dysfunctional times. But that is not the kind of will needed if we would overcome the effects of self-willing.”

With these thoughts in his mind, Victor withdrew from the loggia, to the evident relief of the speaker, whose voice then became shriller as he moved on to the topic of elitism."

 

 

The Friends of Associative Economics Bulletin provides an overview of what is going on around the world in the associative economics movement. The bulletin is viewable as a webpage at www.cfae.biz/fae-bulletin/10Nov/

 
Click here to unsubscribe or edit your subscription

A service provided by the Centre for Associative Economics
Copyright 2011 Centre for Associative Economics. All rights reserved.